How We Tested
Our sleep research team spent over 200 nights testing 27 different mattresses. Each mattress was evaluated across multiple categories: pressure relief using mapping technology, temperature regulation with thermal sensors, motion isolation for couples, edge support, durability through compression testing, and real-world comfort across different sleep positions.
We had testers of varying body types and sleep preferences evaluate each mattress for at least two weeks. Our testing panel included side, back, and stomach sleepers, as well as combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night.
Helix Midnight Luxe
The Helix Midnight Luxe earns our top spot by delivering exceptional comfort for the widest range of sleepers. The hybrid construction combines memory foam layers with individually wrapped coils, providing both contouring pressure relief and responsive support. What sets it apart is the zoned lumbar support system that keeps your spine properly aligned whether you sleep on your side or back. The Tencel cover and gel-infused foam layers help with temperature regulation.
- Excellent zoned lumbar support for spine alignment
- Great for both side and back sleepers
- Premium materials with 15-year warranty
- Premium price point
- May be too soft for strict stomach sleepers
Saatva Classic
The Saatva Classic delivers a luxury hotel mattress experience with its traditional innerspring feel and premium materials. Unlike bed-in-a-box competitors, Saatva offers white-glove delivery with free old mattress removal. The dual coil system provides excellent support and airflow, while the Euro pillow top adds plush comfort. Available in three firmness levels (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm), making it easy to find your perfect match.
- Luxury hotel-quality feel at competitive price
- Free white-glove delivery and mattress removal
- Three firmness options to choose from
- Not available on Amazon - direct order only
- More motion transfer than foam mattresses
Purple Original Mattress
Purple's innovative GelFlex Grid technology offers a sleeping experience unlike any other mattress. The hyper-elastic polymer grid cradles pressure points while remaining cool and breathable. This unique construction is especially beneficial for hot sleepers, as air flows freely through the grid. The Purple Original provides a medium-firm feel with excellent responsiveness for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night.
- Exceptional temperature neutrality for hot sleepers
- Unique GelFlex Grid provides both support and pressure relief
- Highly responsive for easy position changes
- Unique feel may not suit traditional mattress lovers
- Less edge support than hybrid mattresses
Nectar Premier
The Nectar Premier delivers premium memory foam comfort at a mid-range price, making it our Best Value pick. The 12-inch profile features gel-infused memory foam for cooling and a responsive transition layer to prevent that "stuck in the mattress" feeling. Nectar offers one of the best trial periods in the industry at 365 nights, plus a forever warranty. It's an excellent choice for side sleepers and those who want classic memory foam feel.
- Exceptional value with premium features
- 365-night trial and forever warranty
- Excellent pressure relief for side sleepers
- May sleep warm for some
- Limited edge support compared to hybrids
WinkBed
The WinkBed is specifically designed for those with back pain, featuring a three-zone support system that provides extra reinforcement in the lumbar area. The hybrid construction uses gel-infused foam layers over individually wrapped coils for both comfort and support. The Euro-pillow top adds a plush surface feel while maintaining proper spine alignment. Available in four firmness options, including a Plus model for heavier individuals.
- Excellent lumbar support for back pain sufferers
- Four firmness levels including Plus for heavy sleepers
- Strong edge support for easy entry/exit
- Higher motion transfer than foam mattresses
- Heavy and difficult to move
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt
Tempur-Pedic invented memory foam, and the TEMPUR-Adapt showcases their material science expertise. The proprietary TEMPUR material adapts to your body weight, shape, and temperature for personalized comfort. It excels at pressure point relief, making it ideal for those with joint pain or who need serious contouring. The premium price reflects the quality materials and Tempur-Pedic's industry-leading 10-year warranty.
- Industry-leading pressure relief and contouring
- Premium TEMPUR material adapts to your body
- Excellent motion isolation for couples
- Premium price point
- May sleep warm; less cooling than competitors
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
Brooklyn Bedding manufactures their mattresses in their own Arizona factory, cutting out middlemen to offer premium hybrid construction at budget-friendly prices. The Signature Hybrid combines TitanFlex foam with individually encased coils for a balanced feel. Available in three firmness levels, it accommodates most sleep preferences. The responsive surface makes it particularly good for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night.
- Excellent value for hybrid construction
- Three firmness options available
- Responsive and easy to move around on
- Not as plush as luxury competitors
- Shorter trial period than some brands
Frequently Asked Questions
Most mattresses should be replaced every 7-10 years. Signs you need a new mattress include visible sagging, waking up with aches and pains, poor sleep quality, or increased allergy symptoms. Higher-quality mattresses with durable materials may last longer with proper care.
Memory foam offers excellent pressure relief and motion isolation, ideal for side sleepers and couples sensitive to movement. Hybrid mattresses combine foam with innerspring coils for better edge support, cooling, and responsiveness. Hot sleepers and those who need strong edge support often prefer hybrids.
Firmness depends on sleep position and body weight. Side sleepers typically need medium to medium-soft for pressure relief at shoulders and hips. Back sleepers do well with medium to medium-firm. Stomach sleepers need medium-firm to firm for proper spine alignment. Heavier individuals often need firmer options for adequate support.
Quality mattresses in the $1,000-2,000 range typically offer the best value, with durable materials and proper support systems. Budget mattresses under $500 may wear out faster and lack adequate support. Luxury mattresses over $3,000 offer premium materials but often show diminishing returns for most sleepers.
Found this comparison helpful? Share it with others!