How We Tested
We tested each streaming device across multiple TVs, evaluating app performance, interface responsiveness, picture quality, audio support, and remote functionality. We also compared app availability and assessed each platform's voice assistant capabilities.
Roku Streaming Stick 4K
The Roku Streaming Stick 4K delivers excellent 4K HDR streaming with Dolby Vision support at a fantastic price. Roku's interface is clean and unbiased, giving equal prominence to all streaming services. The voice remote works great, and the mobile app adds convenient features like private listening.
- Best value for 4K streaming
- Clean, ad-light interface
- Excellent app selection
- No ecosystem lock-in
- Voice assistant not as capable as Alexa/Google
- No Dolby Atmos over Bluetooth
Apple TV 4K (3rd Generation)
The Apple TV 4K is the premium choice for iPhone users. AirPlay makes screen mirroring effortless, Apple Fitness+ integration is excellent, and the tvOS interface is polished. The A15 Bionic chip ensures buttery-smooth performance, and the new Siri Remote is a significant improvement.
- Best performance and interface polish
- Seamless Apple ecosystem integration
- Privacy-focused
- Excellent gaming with Apple Arcade
- Most expensive option
- Limited value outside Apple ecosystem
Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max
If you're invested in Amazon's ecosystem, the Fire TV Stick 4K Max is the natural choice. Alexa integration is deep, letting you control smart home devices and search across services. Wi-Fi 6 support ensures fast, reliable streaming, and the interface prioritizes Prime Video content.
- Best Alexa integration
- Wi-Fi 6 support
- Good smart home control hub
- Interface heavily promotes Amazon content
- More ads than Roku